بازده روزانه اطلاعات در بازار سهام چین
|کد مقاله||سال انتشار||مقاله انگلیسی||ترجمه فارسی||تعداد کلمات|
|12658||2009||15 صفحه PDF||سفارش دهید||11270 کلمه|
Publisher : Elsevier - Science Direct (الزویر - ساینس دایرکت)
Journal : China Economic Review, Volume 20, Issue 3, September 2009, Pages 527–541
Bid-ask spread is a direct measure of information asymmetry. As such, it can be used to evaluate information efficiency. In this paper, we show that both the quoted and effective spreads on the Shanghai Stock Exchange are extremely high at the open, decrease over the trading day, and experience a small rebound at the close. The spread decreases with share volume, daily trades, and market capitalization, but increases with average trade size. We further examine the beta using the unbiasedness regression from Biais et al. [Biais, B., Hillion, P., Spatt, C. (1999). Price discovery and learning during the pre-opening period in the Paris Bourse. Journal of Political Economy, 107, 1218–1248] and find that intraday prices are efficient and unbiased for more liquid stocks. This suggests that liquidity prompts information-motivated trading, which, in turn, improves information dissemination. Moreover, our findings indicate that small and medium trades are more likely to facilitate the formation of efficient prices at the open and close of the market, while large trades play a more important role during the other trading periods.
Looking at trading mechanisms within different market structures provides insight into the ways financial markets operate. There is a growing literature examining a variety of structural aspects of trading mechanisms across different markets. Market efficiency, price discovery, trading costs, and the behavior of informed and liquidity traders are among the most widely researched and discussed topics. Central to any such research is the relative informational efficiency of market prices. The opening of the Shanghai Stock Exchange in 1990 marked the beginning of an electronic quotation and surveillance system for equity trading in China. Electronic trading allows market participants to observe and track share prices, volume, and trades of any stock on the exchange. Even though the Chinese market has operated for nearly two decades, there have been a relatively limited number of articles studying the behavior of share prices on that market. The Chinese market is well-known for its lack of qualified security analysts, low transparency, uniform tick size, price limits, short-selling restrictions, and dominance of unsophisticated individual investors. These factors contribute to the difficulty in conducting research on the Chinese market. Earlier work that has attempted to explore the efficiency and accuracy of stock markets employs low frequency data which are based on daily, weekly, or monthly trades. In this paper, we use a tick-by-tick dataset to assess the efficiency and price discovery process for share prices on an intraday level. With the dramatic growth in market capitalization over the past decade, the Chinese market has received increased attention from foreign institutional investors. For these investors, the degree of intraday information efficiency has a direct impact on the fair external environment for trading, which, in turn, is beneficial to their investments. This study utilizes a unique dataset which consists of quotes and trades for the 180 component stocks included on the Shanghai Stock Exchange from June 1, 2004 until May 31, 2005. We use this dataset to evaluate the information efficiency of transaction prices, a key dimension of market quality. Analysis of the Chinese data provides an important first step towards understanding the dynamic behavior of share prices in this emerging market. Specifically, we try to answer the question of how price discovery evolves over the trading day. In general, stock prices in a market with greater liquidity, lower trading costs, and fewer restrictions are more likely to move closer to their fundamental values. The Chinese market, with its low transparency, high trading costs, and many restrictions, tends to play a less important role in price discovery. However, our evidence indicates that information efficiency on the Chinese stock market is comparable to other markets, even on an intraday level. As more informative prices facilitate better informed investing and financing decisions,1 our results have significant implications for the real economy. Several studies have discussed information efficiency and price discovery in mature markets. Stoll and Whaley (1990) and Madhavan and Panchapagesan (2000) examine the importance of the specialist to price discovery on the New York Stock Exchange; Biais, Hillion, and Spatt (1999) probe the interaction between price discovery and the learning process before the opening of the Paris Bourse; Flood, Huisman, Koedijk, and Mahieu (1999) show the role that transparency plays in opening spreads and price discovery within an experimental framework; Cao, Ghysels, and Hatheway (2000), and Ciccotello and Hatheway (2000) discuss the impact of pre-opening nonbinding quotes submitted by market makers on Nasdaq; Domowitz and Madhavan (2001) survey price discovery through nonbinding quotes when there is no trading; Davies (2003) examines price discovery by registered traders on the Toronto Stock Exchange; Barclay and Hendershott (2003) analyze the relationship between price discovery and trading; Ellul, Shin, and Tonks (2005) assess the performance of call markets at the open and close of the London Stock Exchange; Comerton-Forde and Rydge (2006) investigate the effect of a call auction design on price efficiency on the Australian Stock Exchange; and Barclay and Hendershott (2008) find that prices discovered through non-trading mechanisms on Nasdaq reveal less information than those discovered through trading mechanisms. This article makes three contributions to the literature. First, due to the presence of controls on capital accounts, the Chinese market is more or less insulated from other mature markets. The ability to look at it in isolation allows us to generalize our findings to other markets and therefore complement similar studies that have already been conducted on those markets. Second, we provide some insight into how the Chinese market is able to produce efficient prices despite loose regulations and trading constraints. This is of interest both academically and practically. Finally, there have been few studies of order-driven and emerging markets such as the Chinese Stock Exchange, as opposed to quote-driven and developed markets. The rest of the paper is arranged as follows. In Section 2, we describe the sample data and provide descriptive statistics. Section 3 compares trading costs on an intraday level. In Section 4, we present the empirical findings. Section 5 concludes the paper.
نتیجه گیری انگلیسی
To some extent, price efficiency is formed through the unwitting behavior of market participants. However, this efficient state doesn't occur instantaneously. It takes time, albeit a very short amount of time, for informed traders to move the market towards efficiency. A primary purpose of this study is to look at information efficiency on the Chinese market on an intraday basis. The Chinese market was chosen as it is a typical example of an emerging market. We first examine intraday trading costs represented by quoted and effective spreads, an indirect measure of information efficiency. Both are more than twice their normal size at the open. The downward trend begins shortly after the open and continues throughout the trading day, with the exception of a small rebound at the close. Traders at the close can receive better prices, on average, than would be available in the pre-close period. The implication is that informed traders become involved in trading at the close to profit from short-lived private information, despite slightly higher trading costs. To complement the analysis of trading costs, the unbiasedness regression developed by Biais et al. (1999) is applied to explore intraday information efficiency. Our results indicate that bias is highest at the open, decreases steadily throughout the trading day, and increases precisely at the close. The significantly biased betas during the first and last 10 min of the trading day concur with the findings on trading costs. As shown in the weighted beta contribution, more than 50% of efficiency discovery takes place in the first half-hour after the open. For stocks with large volume, frequent trades, great market value, or small trade size, the speed of convergence to information efficiency is even faster. Based on these results, investors may wonder when the optimal trading time is on the Chinese market. With the exception of the open and close when trading costs are high, the rest of the trading day is fairly ideal for uninformed investors to enter the market. The second half of the afternoon session is particularly ideal, with the lowest spreads and unbiased beta. Further research is necessary to explain why high spreads and biased prices occur simultaneously at the open and close on the Chinese market. The precise nature of this phenomenon is likely to provide important implications for the optimal design of market structure, trading protocol, and regulatory policy, and therefore information efficiency.