To guarantee a constant quality of manufactured products, it is necessary to optimise the process parameters immediately when deviations of the workpiece quality have been observed. Established methods of quality management are only able to register quality deviations (like the statistical process control) or to analyse them offline with the help of experts (like failure mode and effects analysis). The presented approach develops a process oriented automated quality control for manufacturing in two steps: First, a local quality controller stabilises the product quality to reference values in the pace of workpiece production. In order to obtain the control law for the process parameters, a learning approach is applied. In the second step, the information exchange between the local controllers is established parallel to the workpiece flow in order to obtain an optimised global process. As an example, the method is applied to quality control in the turning process.
In general, a complete manufacturing process can be
modelled as a sequence of local manufacturing subprocesses
numbered by i=l, ..., n in Figure 1. Starting
with the raw material, the workpieces are processed in
the subprocesses in ascending order until the final product
is obtained.
In each subprocess, the quality of the product is threatened
by systematic and random errors. For that reason,
the workpiece quality must be measured and a strategy
has to be found, to use the measured data in order to
compensate at least the systematic errors. In most cases
the relation between the process observation and its
control is highly nonlinear and classical methods of linear
control theory cannot be applied. In most cases, it
usually depends on the process knowledge and experience
of the operators to adjust the parameters of the
machine manually.
Quality Control and Quality Management
In the recent years, methods of process control have
been developed. The statistic process control (SPC)
investigates the measured data with statistic methods in
order to predict developments within a subprocess for
the near future and to give a warning, if a requirement for
quality is violated [I].
the failure mode and effects analysis (FMEA) can be
used in order to list up possible reasons for failures and
to develop suggestions for an improvement [2].
Both methods will support the process operator, but they
are not able to define an appropriate control action to
optimise the workpiece quality immediately and automatically
in a closed loop as shown in Figure 1.
Quality Control and Control Theory
It is characteristic for a controlled closed loop system,
that the determination of the controller output is based
on a continuous measurement as well as on reference
values [3].
The same situation can be found for the case of quality
control: The correction of the controller output is determined
continuously in the pace of the process from
measurement which quantifies quality characteristics of
the product (see Figure 1). It is compared to quality reference
values.
For the investigated class of production systems, the
following properties can be summarised:
Since an in-process measurement is impossible or
too expensive in most cases, the approach is restricted
to a post-process measurement at the end of each subprocess. This can be
applied to discrete manufacturing
and to batch processes. Hence,
the system is discrete in time; the
post process measurement limits
the time pace.
Measurement is related to the
product, whereas the controller
output is applied to the process.
In classical control theory both
values are related to the process.
It is not sufficient to operate the
system in one setpoint. Hence,
the relation between measurement
and controller output is
nonlinear in general
In most cases, no mathematical
model of this relationship is
available.
For real plants, multiple inputs
and outputs must be considered
(MIMO system).
For the classical controller design,
a mathematical model of the plant
is necessary. In the same way the
idea of a model based quality control
has been developed [4] which
uses a model for the interpretation
of the measured data. The control
unit has to determine its output
such that according to the model
the measured deviation will be
compensated as good as possible.
The problem remains that the model has to be developed, which
is a time consuming and difficult task in most cases. In
section 2 a learning algorithm is presented that is able to
obtain a process model from measured data samples. It
shows a fast adaptation of the control law within a sequence
of a few workpieces. Especially in cases where a
sequence of similar workpieces has to be manufactured,
the method seems to be advantageous to reach an optimised
workpiece quality.
Quality Control and Holonic Manufacturing Systems
The described quality control of a single subprocess can
be improved by an information exchange to the preceding
and following subprocess as shown in Figure 2. By
this way, the local system receives information about the
demands of the complete production chain that can be
considered locally.
The local subprocess and its control can be regarded as
an autonomous unit. It is able to cooperate with other
units. These units can be integrated to larger systems,
which model production chains.Such a unit is called holon within the concept of Holonic
Manufacturing Systems [5], [6]. Therefore, the concept
presented in section 3 contributes to a quality related
manufacturing holon.
In this paper, a concept of a model based quality control
for single processes and for production chains has been
presented. It has been shown for the turning process
that a control law can be found within a few time steps,
even if there is no prior control knowledge. To overcome
the difficulty that a process model must be obtained, a
simple learning approach using radial basis functions for
the approximation of the control law has been developed.
Nevertheless, a fast convergence of the adaptation of
the control function can only be expected, when the
dimension of the input vector is limited. The selection of
the dominant quality characteristics and the choice of a
sufficient number of radial basis functions needs an
understanding of the manufacturing process. For quality
control of a process chain, appropriate quality references
{d'a}n d the cost functions G") , V'"' must be defined.
In order to simplify the application of the concept, a software
tool under Matlab has been developed. A software
library of standard holons will be implemented for the
quality control of more complex manufacturing systems.